Best Cushioned Toilet Seats – Top 5 Picks in 2021, Reviews and Buyers Guide

by Dan | Last Updated: January 18, 2021

Our editors independently research, select and recommend the best products. Some of these may be affiliate based, meaning we earn a small commission (at no additional cost to you) if items are purchased.

Padded toilet seats are currently the in thing in bathroom upgradation. Not only do they provide you with maximum comfort, but they are also aesthetically appealing, thus giving your bathroom a contemporary and eye-catching look.

If you want some pampering and added comfort as you go on with your ‘humble business’, then a padded seat might be the deal.

Let’s give you a lead with our list of what we presume to be the best soft toilet seats on the market today.

Top 5 Padded Toilet Seats

Best Overall
Mayfair 13EC 000
  • Mayfair Soft Toilet Seat 13EC 000
  • Our Rating: 9/10
  •  Dimensions:
    17.2x15x3.4"
  •  Color & Shape:
    White
    Round
  •  Material & Weight:
    Wood
    4.4 pounds
  •   Features:
    Easy-Clean, Durability and Comfort, Stylish Designs
  • Price: 
Premium
Mayfair 113CP 000
  • Mayfair Soft Toilet Seat 113CP 000
  • Our Rating: 8/10
  •  Dimensions:
    18.5x14.1x2.9"
  •  Color & Shape:
    White
    Elongated
  •  Material & Weight:
    Wood and Plastic
    4.5 pounds
  •   Features:
    Stylish Design, Cushioned Vinyl
  • Price: 
Budget
Ginsey Solid Hunter Green Seat
  • Ginsey Solid Hunter
  • Our Rating: 8/10
  •  Dimensions:
    18x16x5"
  •  Color & Shape:
    Empire Green
    Elongated/Round
  •  Material & Weight:
    Vinyl
    3.9 pounds
  •   Features:
    Superb Comfort, Durable Hinges Included, Fits All Standard Size Fixtures
  • Price: 
Comfort Seats C1B5R2-00CH Deluxe
  • Comfort Seats C1B5R2-00CH
  • Our Rating: 7/10
  •  Dimensions:
    16x14.4x3.5"
  •  Color & Shape:
    White
    Round
  •  Material & Weight:
    Wood and Vinyl
    6 pounds
  •   Features:
    Strong and Durable, Ergonomically Designed, Simple to Install
  • Price: 
Achim Home Furnishings TOVYSTBK04 17
  • Achim Home Furnishings TOVYSTBK04
  • Our Rating: 7/10
  •  Dimensions:
    17x2.8x15"
  •  Color & Shape:
    Black
    Fits All Standard Sizes
  •  Material & Weight:
    n/a
    2.75 pounds
  •   Features:
    Highly Durable, Covered in Vinyl For Warmth and Softness
  • Price: 

1. Mayfair 13EC 000 – Editor’s Choice

Designed For Round Bowls

Mayfair 13EC 000

This Mayfair product lives up to the brand’s reputation. Its inner core gets molded from wood making it durable, a far cry from the average crappy cardboard seats that crumble under your weight.

Vinyl Cushion

A vinyl cushion makes it soft, comfy and inviting to everyone including your kids.

While this seat is purposely designed for round bowls, it has a sibling with the elongated design (reviewed below). The seat also provides you with unparalleled comfort thanks to the lock tight hinges that ensure that your seat remains intact and doesn’t slide or shift when you sit on it.

Installation of the seat is a piece of cake too. Just take a glimpse at the instructions that ship with it and you are good to go.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B00004T158″ locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Check Price At Amazon[/easyazon_link]

2. Mayfair 113CP 000 – Premium Pick

Stylish Design

Just like it’s sibling above, this elongated version also proves to be worth your dime. What pushes its reputation to the rooftop is the classic non-tarnish chrome hinge. It is durable and easy to fix, unlike the typical dispensable stuff you find in most local stores.

Mayfair 113CP 000

Fits All The Elongated Bowls

The seat fits all the elongated bowls explicitly manufactured in the US and Canada. Moreover the seat sport stylish designs which will might add a good touch to your bathroom’s elegant and contemporary theme.

Not to forget is that the materials which are used to manufacture the seats are eco-friendly, thus going a long way in conserving the environment.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B00004T155″ locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Check Price At Amazon[/easyazon_link]

3. Ginsey Solid Hunter Green Seat – Budget Buy

Offer Your Backside Unrivaled Comfort

Ginsey Solid Hunter Green Seat

This superb toilet seat promises to offer your backside unrivaled comfort every time you sit yourself, due to the high-density form cushioning at your dispensation.

Some essential attributes include durable hinges and an easy to care for vinyl cover. It’s also easy to install. So you won’t have to break a sweat to piece it together.

The only misgiving, we can get from the customer’s reviews is the plastic connectors which can easily snap.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B001CRJO34″ locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Check Price At Amazon[/easyazon_link]

4. Comfort Seats C1B5R2-00CH Deluxe – Corrosion Proof Toilet Seat

High-Density Foam Padding

This ergonomically designed seat might give you good value for your cash. It is assembled using rounded wood and high-density foam padding to guarantee you comfortable visits to the toilet.

Comfort Seats C1B5R2-00CH Deluxe

Ergonomically Designed Seat

What differentiates it from the rest is that it’s corrosion proof.

From the customer reviews, we can attest that the hinges (single top design) are easy to attach securely unlike the ordinary types. Also, installing the seat is a child’s play, you only need a screwdriver to get things done.

The downside with this seat is that the vinyl material tends to stain permanently. Therefore, precautions should be taken when using it.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B001AHKDF4″ locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Check Price At Amazon[/easyazon_link]

5. Achim Home Furnishings TOVYSTBK04 17 – Affordable and Popular

Gives You The Much-Needed Warmth and Softness

This exquisite and elegant seat will provide you with everything that you need on a shoestring budget. It promises to give you the much-needed warmth and softness thanks to the vinyl cover.

Achim Home Furnishings TOVYSTBK04 17This means that you won’t have to dread those midnight nature calls because of hard and cold toilet seats.

Interestingly, the Achim Home Furnishings cushioned seat comes in a wide range of popping colors to choose from.

Easy To Install

Installing the seat is a walk in the park thanks to its easy to install and adjustable hinges. A little perusal through the guide is more than enough information.

Cleaning the seat requires some mild soap and water only, no need for expensive detergents or other unwarranted expenditures.

[easyazon_link identifier=”B008E4868M” locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Check Price At Amazon[/easyazon_link]

Editor’s Choice

[easyazon_image align=”center” identifier=”B00004T158″ locale=”US” src=”https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/31t6LxX8sKL._SL400.jpg” tag=”toptoilets-20″]

Looking objectively at what we have as the best-padded toilet seats, we conclude that the [easyazon_link identifier=”B00004T158″ locale=”US” tag=”toptoilets-20″]Mayfair 13EC 000[/easyazon_link] takes the lead.

This seat is currently the top rated thanks to its quality metal hinges and quality construction that seems like it could hold up for some years.

Best Cushioned Toilet Seats Comparison Chart

Rank:Model:Our Verdict:Price:Our Rating:Dimensions:Color:Shape:Special Features:Material:Weight:Installation Method:Warranty:
#1[easyazon_link identifier="B00004T158" locale="US" tag="toptoilets-20"]Mayfair Soft Toilet Seat 13EC 000[/easyazon_link]Best Overall (Our Pick)$$9/1017.2x15x3.4"WhiteRoundEasy-Clean, Durability and Comfort, Stylish DesignsWood4.4 poundsAdjustable Hinges1 Year Warranty
#2[easyazon_link identifier="B00004T155" locale="US" tag="toptoilets-20"]Mayfair Soft Toilet Seat 113CP 000[/easyazon_link]Premium$$$8/1018.5x14.1x2.9"WhiteElongatedStylish Design, Cushioned VinylWood, Plastic4.5 poundsAdjustable Hinges1 Year Warranty
#3[easyazon_link identifier="B001CRJO34" locale="US" tag="toptoilets-20"]Ginsey Solid Hunter[/easyazon_link]Budget$8/1018x16x5"Empire GreenElongated/RoundSuperb Comfort, Durable Hinges Included, Fits All Standard Size FixturesVinyl3.9 poundsAdjustable HingesCheck With The Manufacturer
#4[easyazon_link identifier="B001AHKDF4" locale="US" tag="toptoilets-20"]Comfort Seats C1B5R2-00CH[/easyazon_link]$$$7/1016x14.4x3.5"WhiteRoundStrong and Durable, Ergonomically Designed, Simple to InstallWood and Vinyl6 poundsAdjustable Hinges and Bumpers1 Year Limited Warranty
#5[easyazon_link identifier="B008E4868M" locale="US" tag="toptoilets-20"]Achim Home Furnishings TOVYSTBK04 17-Inch[/easyazon_link]$$7/1017x2.8x15"BlackFits All Standard Size FixturesHighly Durable, Covered in Vinyl For Warmth and Softness, Easy To InstallCheck With The Manufacturer2.75 poundsAdjustable HingesCheck With The Manufacturer

Best Padded Toilet Seats Buying Guide

  1. ColorChoose a toilet seat that rhymes with the hue of your commode. You are at free to select a color that is suitable for your theme.
  2. QualityPreferably choose a durable product, made of quality materials since it is a long-term investment. Not everyone wants to buy a seat that will break down just few weeks down the line.
  3. Dimensions and MeasurementsAssess the kind of bowl that your cistern has. Is it an elongated or round-front end? Take the needed measures and then find a suitable seat that matches those values.
  4. Ease Of CleaningConsider a toilet seat made of a material that does not give you hell to clean. You might also want to avoid fabrics that develop ugly marks after being cleaned.

 

Why Use A Toilet Seat Cushioned?

Your bathroom is invariably a place where you visit several times a day. Objectively, to make your experience enjoyable and not as some sought of a chore, you need to throw in some add ons such as a padded toilet seat.
The following reasons will give you some insights as to why you should ditch the traditional hard seat and opt for a padded toilet seat:

How To Measure For A New Toilet Seat

Measuring for the best toilet seat can be a real adventure. Since this is not an everyday thing, most homeowners don’t realize that standard seats come in a range of sizes.
But what’s more saddening is that your local home improvement store dealer won’t appreciate you taking your old seat in search for a perfect fit.

There is no other option, therefore, than to pull out your tape and make some serious measurements.

Here is how to measure for a new toilet seat:

  1. Unscrew the seat and the lid from the hinges.
  2. Locate the two bolts where the seat attaches.
  3. Measure from post to post and record the measurement. The standard measurement in the US is around 5-1/2 inches from post to post.
  4. Identify the widest point in the middle of the bowl and measure the width from one outside edge to the other.
  5. Measure the length of the bowl to determine whether it’s elongated or round-shaped. Even if you know the shape of the bowl, just measure to ensure accuracy. Do this by positioning your measuring tape between the two hinge posts to the outermost part at the front of the bowl.

For an elongated seat, this distance should be between 18 and 18-1/2 inches and 16-1/5 inches if you have a round bowl toilet.

It’s always advisable to take the measurements twice to ensure that you have accurate readings before hitting the store.

Again, there are lots of tutorial videos on YouTube that might come in handy too like this one. Check them out if this isn’t clear enough.

Conclusion

An ice cold toilet seat won’t kill you. But it might suck the fun out of life. On the other hand, a padded toilet seat is perhaps the best treat that you could offer your backside.
Besides bringing a little bit of fun and enjoyment as you do your thing, it adds a lot of convenience to the senior citizens, kids, and people suffering from chronic pain or limited mobility.

Dan is the editor in chief and founder of this site, after running into troubles with his own old toilet a while ago. Discussing toilets is not your everyday topic, so let’s talk toilets today.